Efficient Abode

How to Calculate Whether a Time-of-Use Plan Will Actually Save You Money

11 min read

↓ Jump to Action Guide

Your utility probably offered you a time-of-use (TOU) plan by now, with promises of cheaper electricity if you shift your usage. The catch is that the same plan that saves one household $40 a month can cost another household $30 more. Rates on a TOU plan might run 9 cents per kWh overnight and 38 cents per kWh from 4 to 9 p.m., and if most of your power use lands in that expensive window, you lose.

Tools We Recommend

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

The good news is that you do not have to guess. Your utility already tracks how much electricity you use and when you use it, and that data is usually free to download. With a basic spreadsheet or even a pencil and paper, you can compare what you would have paid on a TOU plan against what you actually paid on your current flat rate.

This post walks through two ways to run that comparison: a quick 15-minute estimate using your monthly bills, and a more precise method using hourly smart meter data. We will also cover how to calculate the payback on changes like a smart thermostat or battery that make a TOU plan more profitable.

Savings: 5 to 25% on electricity bills if usage shifts off-peak
Difficulty: Easy
Time: 15 minutes to 1 hour
Payback: Immediate for behavior changes, 2 to 5 years for equipment
💰5 to 25% on electricity bills if usage shifts off-peak
🔧Easy
⏱️15 minutes to 1 hour
📈Immediate for behavior changes, 2 to 5 years for equipment
✓ Renter Safe✓ DIY Friendly✓ Immediate Results

What You’ll Need

Click on an item below to shop for the recommended items for this recipe on Amazon.

🔧Appliance Timer

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

How to Do It


Time: 15 minutes
Cost: $0
Difficulty: Easy
This method gives a rough answer. If the result is within 5% either direction, move on to the detailed method before deciding.
  1. Pull your last 12 monthly bills and write down your total kWh and total dollars for each month. Divide dollars by kWh to get your current average rate (often 14 to 20 cents).
  2. Get the TOU rate sheet from your utility’s website. Note the peak, off-peak, and any mid-peak prices, plus the exact hours and which months they apply.
  3. Estimate what share of your use falls in each window. A rough starting point for a typical home: 25 to 35% peak, 15 to 25% mid-peak, and 40 to 55% off-peak.
  4. Multiply your monthly kWh by each share, then by each rate, and add the three results. Compare that total to your current bill for the same month.
  5. Add up the monthly difference across all 12 months, including any change in fixed fees. If the TOU total is lower by at least 8 to 10%, the plan is worth a closer look.
Time: 45 to 60 minutes
Cost: $0
Difficulty: Medium
Most utilities offer a free Green Button download or an online usage portal. Some even run a bill comparison tool, but verify its math with your own spreadsheet.
  1. Log in to your utility account and download your hourly usage data for the past 12 months. Look for an option labeled Green Button, Download My Data, or Interval Data (CSV format works best).
  2. Open the file in Excel or Google Sheets. Add a column that labels each hour as peak, mid-peak, or off-peak, based on the TOU schedule and the season. A simple IF formula or a lookup table handles this.
  3. Add a second column that multiplies each hour’s kWh by the matching TOU rate. Then add a third column that multiplies the same kWh by your current flat rate.
  4. Sum both columns by month and compare. Also sum the fixed monthly charges for each plan. The plan with the lower total wins.
  5. Run a what-if scenario: move 20 to 30% of your peak kWh to off-peak (laundry, dishwasher, EV charging) and see how the TOU total changes. If the shifted result beats your flat rate by 10% or more, switching makes sense.
  6. Calculate payback on any shifting equipment. Divide the cost of a smart plug, timer, or thermostat by your projected monthly savings. A $130 smart thermostat saving $12 a month pays back in about 11 months.

Why It Works: The Benefits

1

Know Before You Switch

A 30-minute calculation prevents a 12-month commitment to a plan that costs you $200 or more extra per year.

2

Lower Bills for the Right Households

Homes with EVs, electric water heaters, or flexible schedules often save 15 to 25% by moving load to off-peak hours.

3

Targeted Efficiency Spending

Once you see which hours cost you most, you can aim upgrades like a smart thermostat or timer at the specific loads that matter.

4

Reduced Grid Strain

Shifting use out of the 4 to 9 p.m. window helps utilities avoid firing up expensive peaker plants, which is why they offer the discount in the first place.

💰 Savings Impact by Action

Load Shifting15%

Moving laundry, dishwasher, and EV charging to off-peak hours can cut a typical bill by 10 to 20%.

Pre-Cooling10%

Lowering the thermostat before peak and raising it during peak reduces afternoon AC use by up to 10% of monthly cost.

Water Heater Timing8%

Heating water off-peak instead of during evening hours trims water heating costs by 8 to 15%.

Plan Selection12%

Choosing the right plan for your usage pattern, rather than the default, can save 5 to 15% annually.

🏠 Key Concepts Explained

Peak vs. Off-Peak Rate SpreadRate StructureThe gap between your cheapest and most expensive hours drives the whole calculation. A spread of 3 to 1 or wider (such as 10 cents vs. 35 cents) gives you real room to save, while a spread under 2 to 1 rarely justifies the hassle.
Load ShapeUsage PatternYour load shape is the pattern of when you use electricity across a day. Households home during the afternoon, with AC running from 4 to 8 p.m., have a peak-heavy shape that tends to lose money on TOU plans.
Shiftable vs. Fixed LoadsBehaviorDishwashers, laundry, EV charging, and pool pumps can run at 2 a.m. without any comfort penalty. Cooking dinner, lighting, and AC during a heat wave cannot move, so the share of shiftable load determines your upside.
Thermal Mass and Pre-CoolingBuilding ScienceA well-insulated home can be pre-cooled by 2 to 3 degrees before the peak window and coast through it with the AC mostly off. A leaky home loses that stored coolness within an hour or two.
Fixed Charges and MinimumsBillingSome TOU plans carry higher monthly service fees or demand charges that offset energy savings. A $10 higher monthly fee wipes out $120 per year of rate savings before you even start.
Seasonal Rate ChangesRate StructureMany TOU plans use higher summer peak rates and different peak windows in winter. A plan that saves money in spring and fall can lose money in July and August, so you need to test all four seasons.

⚠️ Watch Out: The most common mistake is comparing the TOU plan’s best-case off-peak rate to your current flat rate without checking the peak price and seasonal changes. Also watch for demand charges, which bill you based on your single highest 15 or 60 minute spike in a month, and for plans that lock you into a contract with early termination fees. If you have solar panels or a battery, net metering rules often change under TOU, so ask your utility or an installer for a modeled comparison before switching.
Pro tip: Run the numbers for your worst month, usually July or August, not your average month. If the TOU plan still breaks even or wins in your highest-use summer month, it will almost certainly win the rest of the year.

The Science Behind It

Electricity is hard to store, so the grid has to match supply and demand every second. In the late afternoon and early evening, air conditioners, cooking, lighting, and electronics all run at once while solar output fades. Utilities respond by firing up less efficient peaker plants, which cost far more per kWh to run. TOU rates pass that cost signal to you.

Your home can act like a battery if you plan for it. Drywall, framing, furniture, and air all hold heat, and a typical insulated home can be pre-cooled by 2 to 3 degrees before the peak window begins. Because heat moves at a rate proportional to the temperature difference (Newton’s law of cooling), a home that starts at 73 degrees instead of 76 degrees takes longer to warm up to a tolerable limit. Better insulation and air sealing extend that coasting time from one hour to three or more.

Water heaters work the same way. A 50 gallon tank holds roughly 5 to 6 kWh of thermal energy, and heating it overnight at off-peak rates can cut water heating costs by 30 to 50% compared with a plan that charges peak rates for evening reheats.

Frequently Asked Questions

▼ Why did my bill go up after I switched to a TOU plan?

Most likely, too much of your usage is landing in the peak window, which often runs 4 to 9 p.m. Download your hourly data and check how much of your total kWh falls in those hours. If it is over 40%, either shift loads off-peak or ask your utility about switching back, since many allow it within a trial period.

▼ Can renters do this without landlord permission?

Yes. Switching rate plans is done through your utility account and requires no changes to the property. Smart plugs, appliance timers, and portable window or plug-in devices are all renter friendly, and you can shift laundry and dishwasher use by hand.

▼ How long before I actually notice savings on my bill?

You will see the rate change on your very next bill, but a reliable picture takes 2 to 3 billing cycles. Because seasonal rates can differ, give it a full year before you decide whether to stay.

▼ What if I work from home and use power all day?

Work-from-home households often have higher mid-day use, which may fall in a mid-peak or even a cheap solar-hour window on some plans. Run the hourly calculation, because a plan with a cheap midday rate can actually favor you. Avoid plans where peak starts at noon.

▼ Do I need a smart meter to use a TOU plan?

Yes, your utility needs an interval meter that records usage by the hour. Most utilities have installed these already, but if yours has not, they typically install one at no charge when you enroll.

Quick Tips

  • Set dishwashers, washers, and dryers on delay start so they run after 9 p.m. or whatever your off-peak window begins.
  • Pre-cool your home 2 to 3 degrees lower just before the peak window, then raise the setpoint by 3 to 4 degrees during peak hours.
  • Schedule EV charging for the cheapest overnight hours using the car’s app or the charger’s built-in timer. Most EVs add 25 to 40 miles per hour on a Level 2 charger.
  • Revisit your calculation once a year, because rates, schedules, and your own usage change.

Variations for Your Situation

  • Apartment/Rental: Focus on behavior shifts and plug-in tools. A $15 to $25 smart plug or mechanical timer can delay a window AC, dehumidifier, or space heater, and delay start on your dishwasher and washer costs nothing. Ask whether your unit is individually metered before comparing plans.
  • Tight Budget (under $50): Use only free actions: run the dishwasher and laundry after the peak window, cook with a microwave or slow cooker during peak hours, and unplug idle electronics. A $10 outlet timer is the only purchase you may need, and it can pay back in 1 to 2 months.
  • Older Home (pre-1980): Older homes often have less insulation and more air leakage, so pre-cooling holds for a shorter time. Before relying on TOU savings, seal obvious leaks and add attic insulation toward R-38, which can double your coasting time during the peak window. Also test the plan using your highest-use summer month since AC loads are typically larger.

Tools We Recommend

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.